Navigating Holiday Conversations: What to Say Instead of "When Are You Having a Baby?"

The holidays are a time for celebration, connection, and family gatherings. But for some, the season can bring unintentional discomfort. For individuals or couples facing fertility struggles, seemingly innocent questions like "When are you having a baby?" or "Are you trying yet?" can trigger emotional responses or feelings of inadequacy. These questions may stem from curiosity or good intentions, but they often fail to consider the complexity of fertility issues.

In this blog, we’ll explore alternative conversation starters that promote understanding and empathy, as well as how to offer support when fertility struggles arise. By being mindful of the language we use, we can ensure that holiday conversations are inclusive and considerate of all experiences.

Why Sensitivity Matters

Fertility struggles are often invisible, and people dealing with them may feel isolated or misunderstood. For those who are struggling to conceive, the repeated questioning about family plans can serve as a painful reminder of their challenges. It can be difficult to navigate these conversations, especially when they come from well-meaning family members or friends who may not be aware of the emotional burden they carry.

In some cases, fertility challenges can feel like a personal failure, even though infertility is a medical condition that affects both men and women. When conversations about pregnancy or family-building arise, it’s important to approach these topics with compassion and to avoid putting individuals or couples on the spot.

Three Meaningful Conversation Starters

Instead of asking “When are you having a baby?”, consider one of these thoughtful conversation starters to foster connection without causing discomfort:

  1. "How are you doing this holiday season?" This question allows your loved one to share how they’re feeling emotionally and physically. It gives them the freedom to talk about their fertility journey—if they feel comfortable—without being pressured to respond to a specific timeline. A simple, open-ended question like this shows that you care about them as a person, not just their family-building plans.
  2. "Is there anything I can do to support you right now?" This statement conveys empathy and makes it clear that you are willing to offer help, without the expectation of a particular answer. Whether it’s providing a listening ear, offering assistance with holiday tasks, or simply being a source of emotional support, letting someone know you're there for them can make all the difference.
  3. "What are you most excited about for the holidays this year?" Rather than focusing on family planning, this question invites your loved one to reflect on the positive aspects of the season and their own personal joys. It can lead to meaningful discussions about hobbies, traditions, or upcoming experiences that they’re looking forward to.

What to Do if Fertility Struggles Come Up

If fertility struggles do come up in conversation, it’s important to respond with empathy and care. Here’s how you can support your loved one:

  1. Listen Without Judgment
    If someone opens up about their fertility challenges, the best thing you can do is listen. Avoid offering unsolicited advice or trying to "fix" the situation. Instead, allow them to share their feelings at their own pace. Reassure them that their experiences and emotions are valid.
  2. Be Supportive, Not Invasive
    If your loved one mentions their fertility struggles, avoid probing questions like “What are you doing about it?” or “Have you tried X, Y, or Z?” Instead, offer words of encouragement, such as “I admire your strength through this,” or “I’m here if you need anything.” Let them know that they are not alone in their journey.
  3. Respect Boundaries
    Some individuals may choose not to discuss their fertility issues during the holidays, and that’s okay. If they seem uncomfortable or avoid the topic, gently steer the conversation in another direction. Respecting their privacy will help maintain a supportive, non-judgmental atmosphere.

Take the Next Step: Schedule Your New Patient Appointment Today

At Wellnest Fertility, we understand the importance of approaching fertility with sensitivity and care. Our team is dedicated to providing personalized support, whether you’re just beginning your fertility journey or need assistance with ongoing struggles.

Book Now

Written By Wellnest

The Wellnest Fertility Resource Team collaborates with fertility doctors, knowledge resources, and specialists to develop useful content to support the people of Northeast Utah.